This topic seemed to pop up a few times a week on the old boards, so I thought I mine as well be the first to post it here. Discuss.

What if we loved them both? In so many different ways? Why chose!!

Hopefully this forum doesn't become an outlet to gush about bros... at least provide context for the question. Best musical ability/best song writing/etc.

Scott said in an interview that he used to visit the old boards but the criticism and comparisons between him and Seth made him feel terrible. I think gushing is mainly harmless but those kinds of critiques take an ugly turn real fast. (I hope these boards take some lessons from the old boards of what not to do and how to abide by the band's wishes.)

I would agree with "dontpushmeow"

Chocolate or vanilla. Chunky or creamy. Sweet or unsweet. Whiskey or wine. John or Paul....

They are both amazing. Can't pick one.

I think they are both great but in different ways with different singing abilities, musicianship, and songwriting styles. But they fill for each others weaknesses which is why they are such a great band, they're like Ice and Fire (Bobby being Lukewarm water).

Good Lord

Scott Seth bob joe Paul Tania & Mike!